How Orthopedic Practices Should Respond to Negative Patient Reviews

November 20, 2024


Let’s set the scene: You’ve just seen a patient who needed help with their aching knee. While in your care, they seemed thrilled—praising your soothing explanations and your collection of orthopedic-themed puns (because, who doesn’t appreciate a good “kneedy” joke?). Fast-forward a week, and you spot a 1-star review on Google, accompanied by a comment about a “horrendous” experience.

What gives? Now, you’re frustrated, questioning your bedside manner, and wondering what to do next. Should you respond? Should you ignore it? Should you write a 10-page rebuttal filled with medical facts and GIFs of angry kittens?

Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Here’s how to respond to those less-than-stellar reviews like a pro, keeping your cool and reputation intact.

Disappointed young woman

Why Online Reviews Matter for Orthopedic Practices

Consider this:

  • 90% of patients consult online reviews before booking an appointment.
  • 70% of patients say online reviews are as important as a provider’s credentials.
  • 42% of people won’t visit a practice with less than a three-star rating.

Translation? Your reviews aren’t just a side dish—they’re the main course in your marketing menu. Positive reviews help build trust and draw in new patients, while negative reviews, if handled right, can be a chance to shine.

Be Proactive: Encourage Positive Reviews

The best way to manage negative reviews is to balance them out with an avalanche of positive ones. Here’s how:

  • Deliver Outstanding Care: From scheduling to surgery, make every step seamless and stress-free. The happier your patients, the more likely they’ll share the love.
  • Ask Nicely: A simple, “We’d love to hear your feedback,” post-treatment can go a long way. Bonus points if you make it easy with a QR code or a link to your review page.
  • Use Reputation Management Tools: Tools like BirdEye can help you track and encourage reviews, making the process effortless for you and your patients.

Remember, even the most stellar practices will face a rogue negative review. It’s not the end of the world—just an opportunity to flex your professionalism.

How to Respond to a Negative Review

Responding to negative reviews is an art, much like finding the perfect angle for an X-ray. Here’s your step-by-step guide:

  1. Breathe: First things first, take a deep breath. One negative review doesn’t mean your practice is doomed.
  2. Respond Quickly: Don’t let it linger. Responding within a few days shows you care and take feedback seriously.
  3. Keep It Broad: Avoid discussing specifics of their treatment—HIPAA is no joke, folks. Instead, acknowledge their concern and invite them to discuss it offline.

Example Response:

“Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your experience and take concerns like this seriously. Please give us a call so we can address this directly and ensure your concerns are resolved.”

  1. Be Empathetic: Even if the review feels unfair, a kind tone goes a long way. Think of your response as an open letter to every potential patient reading it.

What NOT to Do:

  • Don’t Share Private Info: Saying, “Actually, you didn’t even need that MRI,” is not only a bad look—it’s illegal. HIPAA violations are the stuff of nightmares.
  • Don’t Get Defensive: A snarky, “You’re wrong,” reply might feel satisfying but won’t win you any new patients. Stay classy.
  • Don’t Ignore It: Silence might seem safe, but it’ll just make future patients assume the review is accurate.

Turning Lemons Into Lemonade (Without Straining a Wrist)

Negative reviews don’t have to sour your online presence. In fact, a well-crafted response can showcase your commitment to patient care and professionalism. Use these moments to demonstrate that you’re a compassionate, approachable expert—someone who truly listens.

Ready to boost your online reputation? Let’s get those 5-star reviews rolling in and make sure your orthopedic practice stands tall (pun intended).